21 October 2005
Fingerprints fail for under-sixes
SA Mathieson
Fingerprint-based biometric technology is impractical for children
under the age of six, according to research by TNO, the Dutch statutory
technology research organisation. TNO found that facial recognition
can be used for young children, although with adaptations to standard
hardware.
Ruud van Munster, TNO senior project manager for security and biometrics,
told the Biometrics 2005 conference in Westminster yesterday (20
October) that there was almost no previous information available
on whether biometrics could be taken from children. However, he
said: “In the EU, there is a resolution in which it is stated
there will be biometrics in passports and travel documents, and
there is no exception for age.” This will apply 36 months
after the EU issues technical standards.
TNO carried out research on a relatively small sample of 161 children
aged from birth to 12, with at least five children for each year
of age. Fingerprints and facial images were successfully taken from
all the children aged seven and over, with success defined by a
NIST quality check for fingerprints and a biometric verification
check for the facial image.
But no infants from birth to two years old could be enrolled for
fingerprints, along with just 8% of three-year-olds. “Babies
can really make a very strong fist,” van Munster commented.
The fingerprint success rate rose with age, to 50% of four-year-olds,
67% of five-year-olds and 89% of six-year-olds. Van Munster said
that results were improved by wiping children’s fingers with
a wet cloth to remove stickiness, then a dry one, to get the best
level of humidity.
Facial images were much more successful, taken with 77% success
for the group from birth to two, and at least 89% from all age bands
above three years. Van Munster said that a trusted person needed
to be present to reassure children, adding that TNO had used hand-puppets
to get the subjects to look at the camera.
He said that a greater degree of zoom should be used to get a large
enough facial image, and recommended a fast shutter speed: “Because
of the mobility of young people, we had blurred images,” he
said.
© SA Mathieson 2005.
Back to news index
|