US Torture Report Becomes a CIA Vs. Congress Political Issue


Related Links

Related Stories

  • Less than Half of RSA Conference Attendees Think NSA Surveillance is Wrong
    Even though Edward Snowden’s revelations about NSA mass surveillance programs have dominated headlines since last year and sparked an ongoing trend toward “transparency” on the part of the tech giants, it turns out that infosecurity professionals aren’t quite as concerned as the general public or some politicians.
  • TrustyCon 2014: NSA Surveillance “a benign enemy”, says Bruce Schneier
    Reuters Technology reporter Joseph Menn interviewed security expert Bruce Schneier in front of last week’s TrustyCon audience in San Francisco, where the security expert provided his analysis of the government surveillance controversy
  • TrustyCon 2014: Government Surveillance – The View from Outside Washington
    A group of speakers who were originally scheduled to appear at this year’s RSA Conference in San Francisco gathered for their own one-day event. The theme, rather than security, was trust in computing, with numerous discussions about how the US and other nations access the data traversing the information age.
  • CSA Summit 2014: NSA Surveillance a Pre-cursor to Police State, Says Former US Cyber Czar
    The CSA Summit at this year’s RSA Conference kicked off with a keynote by Richard Clarke, former presidential advisor. Discussing the recent NSA surveillance controversy, the counter-terrorism and cybersecurity expert declared technology is currently available for the US government, and other nations around the world, “to create a ubiquitous, omniscient police surveillance state.”
  • Obama Announces NSA and Surveillance Policy Reforms
    US president Barack Obama addressed the nation on Friday, laying out a set of reforms for government intelligence-gathering activities meant to reassure a public that has been increasingly vocal about privacy concerns in the wake of Edward Snowden’s NSA snooping revelations.

Top 5 Stories


US Torture Report Becomes a CIA Vs. Congress Political Issue

07 March 2014

Amid new accusations that the CIA has been monitoring the computers of Senate aides and a carefully worded letter from Senator Mark Udall to President Obama that seems to indicate the president was aware of the practice, Senator Martin Heinrich released a statement saying, "The Senate Intelligence Committee oversees the CIA, not the other way around."

This is tantamount to a declaration of political war between Congress and the CIA. Udall's letter says, "It is essential that the Committee be able to do its oversight work – consistent with our constitutional principle of the separation of powers – without the CIA posing impediments or obstacles as it does today." He doesn't specify those impediments or obstacles, but he starts the paragraph, "As you are aware..."

It is believed that he is referring both to the CIA's refusal to declassify a damning 6000 page report into torture allegations during the Bush administration, and also to new accusations that the CIA has been monitoring Senate computers. Earlier this week McClatchy DC reported that the Justice Department has been asked to investigate allegations of malfeasance by the CIA. "The criminal referral may be related to what several knowledgeable people said was CIA monitoring of computers used by Senate aides to prepare the study. The monitoring may have violated an agreement between the committee and the agency," says the report.

Since so much to do with the CIA and the NSA is automatically 'classified' there is little explicit reporting. Nevertheless, in January 2014 Sen Ron Wyden explicitly asked CIA chief John Brennan, "Does the federal Computer Fraud and Abuse Act apply to the CIA?" Techdirt said at the time, "When Senators Ron Wyden and Mark Udall ask questions to senior intelligence community officials in open hearings, it's not because they don't know the answers, but because they do, and they have information that they think should be public... Given all this," it concludes, "how long will it be until we discover 'explosive' revelations about the CIA that confirm what Wyden and Udall have been hinting at?"

The heart of the problem is the 6300 page Intelligence Committee report on the CIA torture allegations which the CIA has classified and refused to release. It is believed to be damning. "Instead," says Heinrich, "the CIA has consistently tried to cast doubt on the accuracy and quality of this report by publicly making false representations about what is and is not in it."

However, it appears that the CIA has done its own, much shorter internal review that apparently supports the main findings of the Committee's report – but that too was meant to remain secret. It is suggested that the agency monitored the Senate computers in an attempt to find out how this internal document was discovered. "The CIA searched computers intended to be used solely by the Senate Intelligence Committee," reports The Washington Post, "in an apparent effort to determine how committee staff members gained access to a draft version of an internal agency review of its controversial interrogation program, U.S. officials said."

But the CIA has come out fighting. “I am deeply dismayed that some members of the Senate have decided to make spurious allegations about CIA actions that are wholly unsupported by the facts,” CIA Director Brennan said in a statement Wednesday. “I am very confident that the appropriate authorities reviewing this matter will determine where wrongdoing, if any, occurred in either the Executive Branch or Legislative Branch. Until then, I would encourage others to refrain from outbursts that do a disservice to the important relationship that needs to be maintained between intelligence officials and Congressional overseers.”

This article is featured in:
Internet and Network Security


Comment on this article

You must be registered and logged in to leave a comment about this article.

We use cookies to operate this website and to improve its usability. Full details of what cookies are, why we use them and how you can manage them can be found by reading our Privacy & Cookies page. Please note that by using this site you are consenting to the use of cookies. ×